As many professionals in mortgage servicing and loss mitigation already know, the metrics that dominate housing coverage — prices, inventory, mortgage rates — tend to be trailing indicators. By the time they move in a meaningful direction, the underlying conditions driving them have often been building for months.
TAKE THE INMAN INTEL INDEX SURVEY
Viewed through that lens, several indicators now clearly indicate that a distressed housing cycle is already forming. These indicators form a pattern we’ve seen in every single previous distressed housing cycle. None of them is particularly subtle at this point.
In this article, we will take a look at four specific indicators in the credit market that signal consumer stress and how that may impact the real estate market.
Indicator 1: Delinquency data is shifting
The Mortgage Bankers Association tracks how loans move through successive stages of delinquency — 30 days late, 60 days, 90 days and into default. Once loans begin progressing through those stages, the distressed property pipeline is already forming.
These roll rates, as servicers call them, have been climbing away from the historic lows that followed pandemic-era stimulus programs and foreclosure moratoriums. The overall trend is gradual, which may be why it hasn’t attracted more attention. But the composition of where the stress is concentrated matters as much as the overall number.
FHA-insured mortgages are now showing delinquency rates in the range of 11 percent to 12 percent, considerably higher than those for conventional loans. That’s significant because FHA borrowers represent a large share of the buyers who entered the market during the peak years of 2021 through 2025 — people who qualified with higher debt-to-income ratios, put down relatively small amounts and started with limited financial reserves.
When those borrowers reach the 90-day mark, the realistic resolution paths narrow considerably. While loan modification sounds like a workable solution, it’s far less effective than policymakers assume.
For a household already devoting 60 percent or more of gross income to housing and debt, a modified payment schedule often addresses the symptom rather than the underlying problem. This is not sustainable, and at that level of financial stress, loan modifications are really only delaying the inevitable.
Indicator 2: The ‘seriously underwater’ count is understated
Roughly 1.2 million homeowners met the standard industry definition of “seriously underwater” as of early 2025, per Cotality’s Q1 2025 Homeowner Equity Report. That designation, however, is reserved for homeowners whose mortgage balance exceeded their home’s value by at least 25 percent. That number has been rising each quarter. It’s also a massive undercount.
Standard negative equity calculations compare outstanding loan balances against estimated property values. They don’t include the actual cost to sell. In most markets, commissions, closing costs, concessions and transfer taxes add up to somewhere between 8 and 10 percent of the sale price.
A homeowner who looks modestly above water on paper may find that selling actually requires bringing cash to closing. Once those transaction costs are included in the calculation, the number of borrowers in genuinely distressed equity positions more than doubles.
An additional 3 million to 4 million homeowners beyond the 1.2 million figure may have equity that’s technically positive but functionally insufficient to exit through a conventional sale — which means a short sale may be the most viable path available to them, even if they don’t fully recognize that yet.
Indicator 3: Consumer credit is sending the same signal
Housing stress rarely develops in isolation. Instead, it tends to travel together with consumer credit stress, and the broader credit picture cannot be ignored. U.S. credit card balances have surpassed $1.28 trillion, the highest level on record, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, with delinquency rates on those balances rising at the same time.
Subprime auto loan delinquencies have climbed past 6.9 percent at the 60-plus-day mark, per Cox Automotive market data, while overall auto loan delinquencies are running close to 5 percent at 30 days past due. Vehicle inventories have built up considerably as consumers pull back.
Historically, deteriorating performance in auto loans and credit cards has appeared several quarters before broader housing stress. The borrowers under pressure in those categories and the borrowers most at risk in the mortgage market overlap considerably — younger, lower-income households carrying debt from multiple directions simultaneously.
Indicator 4: The cost of ownership keeps rising
Another driver of borrower stress is the continued rise in housing costs beyond the mortgage itself. Mortgage underwriting captures principal, interest, taxes and insurance at the time of origination. What it can’t capture is how those costs change afterward.
Property taxes have increased materially across many markets. HOA fees have risen. Maintenance costs have accumulated, particularly for first-time buyers who purchased older homes because newer construction was out of reach. And insurance premiums have become genuinely volatile in a number of states — with some homeowners in coastal and southern markets absorbing increases that bear little resemblance to what they budgeted for when they bought.
Each of these costs pushes effective debt-to-income ratios higher for borrowers who were already near their limits. For households with no meaningful financial buffer, even a single unexpected expense can be enough to tip a stretched budget into delinquency.
Where this is heading
These indicators don’t point to an imminent systemic collapse. They point to something more targeted: a growing pipeline of distressed borrowers, concentrated in specific loan types and specific geographies — particularly markets that saw aggressive price appreciation between 2020 and 2023 and are now also contending with elevated insurance costs. Florida, Texas, Arizona and Georgia are among the states already showing early stress patterns.
These are not hypothetical warning signs, but rather, they’re the early stages of a distressed housing cycle that has already begun.
The forming distressed property cycle will likely be measured in years, not quarters. For servicers, lenders and real estate professionals who work this side of the market, the preparation window is open now, and it won’t stay open indefinitely.
The train has left the station. The only remaining question is how large the distressed property pipeline will ultimately become.
Michael Krein is President of the National REO Brokers Association (NRBA) and Managing Partner of House Karma. Connect with Michael on LinkedIn or Facebook.
